The influence of listeners’ singing experience and the number of singers on the understanding of sung text

Philip Fine, Jane Ginsborg, Christopher Barlow

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Published conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

An important aspect of perceiving sung music is understanding the
words. Previous research has suggested several factors affecting the intelligibility of sung text. This study investigates two of those factors: the
number of singers and the singing expertise of the listener. We expected
more singers to cause greater variability in the acoustic signal and be
harder to comprehend. Listeners who are themselves experienced singers
are more likely to be attuned to factors affecting singers’ diction and were
expected to be better than non-singers at understanding the sung text.
Forty eight participants, half accomplished singers and half self-reported
non-singers, listened to four 8-bar unaccompanied songs twice (in order
to test for familiarity) and wrote out the texts as they heard them. Two
performances were given by a soloist, two by a trio of singers in unison.
Participants were significantly better at understanding the words on the
second hearing than the first, and singers significantly better than nonsingers overall. There was no effect of the number of singers. Hence familiarity and singing experience both benefited sung text understanding.
An effect of the number of singers may be more apparent when comparing a soloist with a choir.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationInternational Symposium on Performance Science 2009
EditorsAaron Williamon, Sharman Pretty, Ralph Buck
PublisherAssociation Europeen des Conservatoires
ISBN (Print)978-94-90306-01-4
Publication statusPublished - 2009

Fingerprint

Singers
Listeners
Soloist
Familiarity
Intelligibility
Diction
Hearing
Trio
Expertise
Unison
Acoustics
Song
Music
Causes

Cite this

Fine, P., Ginsborg, J., & Barlow, C. (2009). The influence of listeners’ singing experience and the number of singers on the understanding of sung text. In A. Williamon, S. Pretty, & R. Buck (Eds.), International Symposium on Performance Science 2009 Association Europeen des Conservatoires.
Fine, Philip ; Ginsborg, Jane ; Barlow, Christopher. / The influence of listeners’ singing experience and the number of singers on the understanding of sung text. International Symposium on Performance Science 2009. editor / Aaron Williamon ; Sharman Pretty ; Ralph Buck. Association Europeen des Conservatoires, 2009.
@inproceedings{5c4e19f796fc45a09d5760f02b81ea38,
title = "The influence of listeners’ singing experience and the number of singers on the understanding of sung text",
abstract = "An important aspect of perceiving sung music is understanding thewords. Previous research has suggested several factors affecting the intelligibility of sung text. This study investigates two of those factors: thenumber of singers and the singing expertise of the listener. We expectedmore singers to cause greater variability in the acoustic signal and beharder to comprehend. Listeners who are themselves experienced singersare more likely to be attuned to factors affecting singers’ diction and wereexpected to be better than non-singers at understanding the sung text.Forty eight participants, half accomplished singers and half self-reportednon-singers, listened to four 8-bar unaccompanied songs twice (in orderto test for familiarity) and wrote out the texts as they heard them. Twoperformances were given by a soloist, two by a trio of singers in unison.Participants were significantly better at understanding the words on thesecond hearing than the first, and singers significantly better than nonsingers overall. There was no effect of the number of singers. Hence familiarity and singing experience both benefited sung text understanding.An effect of the number of singers may be more apparent when comparing a soloist with a choir.",
author = "Philip Fine and Jane Ginsborg and Christopher Barlow",
year = "2009",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-94-90306-01-4",
editor = "Aaron Williamon and Pretty, {Sharman } and Buck, {Ralph }",
booktitle = "International Symposium on Performance Science 2009",
publisher = "Association Europeen des Conservatoires",

}

Fine, P, Ginsborg, J & Barlow, C 2009, The influence of listeners’ singing experience and the number of singers on the understanding of sung text. in A Williamon, S Pretty & R Buck (eds), International Symposium on Performance Science 2009. Association Europeen des Conservatoires.

The influence of listeners’ singing experience and the number of singers on the understanding of sung text. / Fine, Philip; Ginsborg, Jane; Barlow, Christopher.

International Symposium on Performance Science 2009. ed. / Aaron Williamon; Sharman Pretty; Ralph Buck. Association Europeen des Conservatoires, 2009.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Published conference proceedingConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - The influence of listeners’ singing experience and the number of singers on the understanding of sung text

AU - Fine, Philip

AU - Ginsborg, Jane

AU - Barlow, Christopher

PY - 2009

Y1 - 2009

N2 - An important aspect of perceiving sung music is understanding thewords. Previous research has suggested several factors affecting the intelligibility of sung text. This study investigates two of those factors: thenumber of singers and the singing expertise of the listener. We expectedmore singers to cause greater variability in the acoustic signal and beharder to comprehend. Listeners who are themselves experienced singersare more likely to be attuned to factors affecting singers’ diction and wereexpected to be better than non-singers at understanding the sung text.Forty eight participants, half accomplished singers and half self-reportednon-singers, listened to four 8-bar unaccompanied songs twice (in orderto test for familiarity) and wrote out the texts as they heard them. Twoperformances were given by a soloist, two by a trio of singers in unison.Participants were significantly better at understanding the words on thesecond hearing than the first, and singers significantly better than nonsingers overall. There was no effect of the number of singers. Hence familiarity and singing experience both benefited sung text understanding.An effect of the number of singers may be more apparent when comparing a soloist with a choir.

AB - An important aspect of perceiving sung music is understanding thewords. Previous research has suggested several factors affecting the intelligibility of sung text. This study investigates two of those factors: thenumber of singers and the singing expertise of the listener. We expectedmore singers to cause greater variability in the acoustic signal and beharder to comprehend. Listeners who are themselves experienced singersare more likely to be attuned to factors affecting singers’ diction and wereexpected to be better than non-singers at understanding the sung text.Forty eight participants, half accomplished singers and half self-reportednon-singers, listened to four 8-bar unaccompanied songs twice (in orderto test for familiarity) and wrote out the texts as they heard them. Twoperformances were given by a soloist, two by a trio of singers in unison.Participants were significantly better at understanding the words on thesecond hearing than the first, and singers significantly better than nonsingers overall. There was no effect of the number of singers. Hence familiarity and singing experience both benefited sung text understanding.An effect of the number of singers may be more apparent when comparing a soloist with a choir.

M3 - Conference contribution

SN - 978-94-90306-01-4

BT - International Symposium on Performance Science 2009

A2 - Williamon, Aaron

A2 - Pretty, Sharman

A2 - Buck, Ralph

PB - Association Europeen des Conservatoires

ER -

Fine P, Ginsborg J, Barlow C. The influence of listeners’ singing experience and the number of singers on the understanding of sung text. In Williamon A, Pretty S, Buck R, editors, International Symposium on Performance Science 2009. Association Europeen des Conservatoires. 2009