Empirical Study on the Influence of Procurement Method on Last Planner® System Implementation

Emmanuel Itodo Daniel, Christine Pasquire, Graham Dickens, Ramesh Marasini

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Published conference proceedingConference contribution

Abstract

Previous studies have examined various factors that influence the implementation of the Last Planner System (LPS) in construction projects. However, there is limited documented evidence on the influence of procurement methods on the implementation of the LPS. The aim of this study, therefore; is to understand the influence of some selected procurement methods on the implementation of the LPS using case study approach. Three in-depth case studies were conducted on building and highways projects in the UK. The projects were managed with the LPS principles with dissimilar procurement methods. In addition to document analysis and physical observation, 28 in-depth-interviews were conducted.
The investigation shows that the prevailing traditional mindset exhibited by the designers in the traditional design bid build (DBB) influences the quality of promises and commitments that could be made during the lookahead planning. From the study, it seems no single procurement method is a sure way to the full application of the LPS process on a project. The study observes that irrespective of the procurement route used, a mindset change towards collaboration among the different stakeholders on the project is fundamental to successful LPS implementation. For instance, on projects where DBB was used and the subcontractors were in framework agreement, the LPS implementation worked well among the subcontractors. The study recommends that the procurement approach to be used on LPS projects should not be too firm, but lithe enough to integrate collaborative working among the different stakeholders on the project for a smooth workflow.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publication26th International Group for Lean Construction Conference Chennai, India
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2018

Fingerprint

Planning

Cite this

Daniel, E. I., Pasquire, C., Dickens, G., & Marasini, R. (2018). Empirical Study on the Influence of Procurement Method on Last Planner® System Implementation. In 26th International Group for Lean Construction Conference Chennai, India
Daniel, Emmanuel Itodo ; Pasquire, Christine ; Dickens, Graham ; Marasini, Ramesh. / Empirical Study on the Influence of Procurement Method on Last Planner® System Implementation. 26th International Group for Lean Construction Conference Chennai, India. 2018.
@inproceedings{c67aa513622a455bae85134491347c7a,
title = "Empirical Study on the Influence of Procurement Method on Last Planner{\circledR} System Implementation",
abstract = "Previous studies have examined various factors that influence the implementation of the Last Planner System (LPS) in construction projects. However, there is limited documented evidence on the influence of procurement methods on the implementation of the LPS. The aim of this study, therefore; is to understand the influence of some selected procurement methods on the implementation of the LPS using case study approach. Three in-depth case studies were conducted on building and highways projects in the UK. The projects were managed with the LPS principles with dissimilar procurement methods. In addition to document analysis and physical observation, 28 in-depth-interviews were conducted. The investigation shows that the prevailing traditional mindset exhibited by the designers in the traditional design bid build (DBB) influences the quality of promises and commitments that could be made during the lookahead planning. From the study, it seems no single procurement method is a sure way to the full application of the LPS process on a project. The study observes that irrespective of the procurement route used, a mindset change towards collaboration among the different stakeholders on the project is fundamental to successful LPS implementation. For instance, on projects where DBB was used and the subcontractors were in framework agreement, the LPS implementation worked well among the subcontractors. The study recommends that the procurement approach to be used on LPS projects should not be too firm, but lithe enough to integrate collaborative working among the different stakeholders on the project for a smooth workflow.",
author = "Daniel, {Emmanuel Itodo} and Christine Pasquire and Graham Dickens and Ramesh Marasini",
year = "2018",
month = "7",
language = "English",
booktitle = "26th International Group for Lean Construction Conference Chennai, India",

}

Daniel, EI, Pasquire, C, Dickens, G & Marasini, R 2018, Empirical Study on the Influence of Procurement Method on Last Planner® System Implementation. in 26th International Group for Lean Construction Conference Chennai, India.

Empirical Study on the Influence of Procurement Method on Last Planner® System Implementation. / Daniel, Emmanuel Itodo; Pasquire, Christine; Dickens, Graham; Marasini, Ramesh.

26th International Group for Lean Construction Conference Chennai, India. 2018.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Published conference proceedingConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - Empirical Study on the Influence of Procurement Method on Last Planner® System Implementation

AU - Daniel, Emmanuel Itodo

AU - Pasquire, Christine

AU - Dickens, Graham

AU - Marasini, Ramesh

PY - 2018/7

Y1 - 2018/7

N2 - Previous studies have examined various factors that influence the implementation of the Last Planner System (LPS) in construction projects. However, there is limited documented evidence on the influence of procurement methods on the implementation of the LPS. The aim of this study, therefore; is to understand the influence of some selected procurement methods on the implementation of the LPS using case study approach. Three in-depth case studies were conducted on building and highways projects in the UK. The projects were managed with the LPS principles with dissimilar procurement methods. In addition to document analysis and physical observation, 28 in-depth-interviews were conducted. The investigation shows that the prevailing traditional mindset exhibited by the designers in the traditional design bid build (DBB) influences the quality of promises and commitments that could be made during the lookahead planning. From the study, it seems no single procurement method is a sure way to the full application of the LPS process on a project. The study observes that irrespective of the procurement route used, a mindset change towards collaboration among the different stakeholders on the project is fundamental to successful LPS implementation. For instance, on projects where DBB was used and the subcontractors were in framework agreement, the LPS implementation worked well among the subcontractors. The study recommends that the procurement approach to be used on LPS projects should not be too firm, but lithe enough to integrate collaborative working among the different stakeholders on the project for a smooth workflow.

AB - Previous studies have examined various factors that influence the implementation of the Last Planner System (LPS) in construction projects. However, there is limited documented evidence on the influence of procurement methods on the implementation of the LPS. The aim of this study, therefore; is to understand the influence of some selected procurement methods on the implementation of the LPS using case study approach. Three in-depth case studies were conducted on building and highways projects in the UK. The projects were managed with the LPS principles with dissimilar procurement methods. In addition to document analysis and physical observation, 28 in-depth-interviews were conducted. The investigation shows that the prevailing traditional mindset exhibited by the designers in the traditional design bid build (DBB) influences the quality of promises and commitments that could be made during the lookahead planning. From the study, it seems no single procurement method is a sure way to the full application of the LPS process on a project. The study observes that irrespective of the procurement route used, a mindset change towards collaboration among the different stakeholders on the project is fundamental to successful LPS implementation. For instance, on projects where DBB was used and the subcontractors were in framework agreement, the LPS implementation worked well among the subcontractors. The study recommends that the procurement approach to be used on LPS projects should not be too firm, but lithe enough to integrate collaborative working among the different stakeholders on the project for a smooth workflow.

M3 - Conference contribution

BT - 26th International Group for Lean Construction Conference Chennai, India

ER -

Daniel EI, Pasquire C, Dickens G, Marasini R. Empirical Study on the Influence of Procurement Method on Last Planner® System Implementation. In 26th International Group for Lean Construction Conference Chennai, India. 2018